This looks like a job for Curt Swan.
So the latest Question of the Week over at Trouble with Comics was about our favorite penciller/inker teams, and…well, I won’t play coy and say “you gotta go there to find out my choice” since I’m going to post a scan of their work right here, but you should go and read what we all had to say, anyway. I get a bit…florid in talking about my pick, but it’s borne of enthusiasm for the work, what can I say.
I did send a scan along with my entry just to show what I was talking about, but it was a tad large, and may have disrupted the flow of the article. However, I don’t care whether or not anything I do here interrupts any kind of flow, so here’s the pic from Superman #247 (January 1972) by Elliot S! Maggin, Curt Swan and Murphy Anderson:
Just look how torn Superman is in that second panel. That’s a man about to make a decision he doesn’t want to make. But you can read more about what I think about Swan and Anderson’s artistic teamwork right here.
Swan has been paired up with a few interesting inkers: Al Williamson over Swan sometimes mostly just looked like a full Williamson art job, but it was still an odd if enjoyable combo that echoed Anderson’s work in the facial expression department, like in this example from Superman #416 (February 1986):
A Twitter pal brought up George Perez’s inking of Swan in the first half of Alan Moore’s “Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?” story (Superman #423, September 1986) which brought a slick richness to the art:
And I’ve mentioned in the past Kurt Schaffenberger’s inking over Swan, though the primary example is, as I mentioned at that link, too obscured by the terrible printing. But the other half of that Moore story, from Action #583 (September 1986), we get a better look at Kurt’s smooth, expressive lines over Curt’s pencils:
And then of course, there’s Curt Swan inking Curt Swan (in more ways than one!), from Superman Annual #9 (1983):
Man, Swan was always the best, and that he was almost always paired with wonderful collaborators couldn’t help but make his work shine. There’s a big Curt Swan-sized hole in the comics artform ever since his passing, but thank goodness there’s just so much of work left behind that we can still enjoy.
That will always be MY Superman
Yay! Curt Swan was amazing. My favorite Swan collaborator was George Klein:
http://comicbookdb.com/graphics/comic_graphics/1/91/49370_20060707140310_large.jpg
Their work was so crisp and clean. Really beautiful.
great choices Mike!
This is probably my favorite Curt Swan Superman cover ever. And I now notice that it was inked by the aforementioned George Klein.
http://www.comics.org/issue/20963/cover/4/
Anyway, this is the pinnacle of comic book madness for me, and why I still love comics at my slightly-more-advanced-than-Mike-Sterling age
Yay for twitter pals! I can’t get over how much that Williamson-inked face looks like Kirk Alyn.
I think the only modern artist that hits any of the same notes as Swan is Chris Weston. I can imagine him doing a Superman story in The Master’s style.
I have to say that George Klein was my favorite inker for Swan (and over John Buscema too!). Their work on the mid-60’s Superboy & the Legion stuff is just beautiful.
I said the other day when Anderson died that, there are artists and teams I like more, but Swanderson is, and always will be, the gold standard.